Utah cheddar rubbed with Hatch Chiles

This cheese is an expression of love for the landscape of the American Southwest; the rind is almost as stunning as a Canyonlands vista. Beautifully layered like Entrada Sandstone, the paste of Red Butte is tumbled with Hatch Chiles and complex flavors.

3% of gross sales are donated back to Red Butte Garden, our local botanical garden.  

What does it taste like?

Creamy and smoky with a proper balance of heat. The coriander in the rub on the rind gives Red Butte a mellow lemony undertone. The New Mexico Hatch Chiles in the paste provide depth and smokiness.   


  • Crisp lager
  • Pilsner
  • Honestly, Red Butte is great with almost all beers
  • Bloody Mary


  • Salami
  • Assortment of pickled/brined veggies
  • Olives
  • Crusty Bread
  • Superb melting capabilities, perfect for a burger

Ingredient info

Vegetarian rennet, cow's milk, all ingredients rubbed on the rind are organic, this is a gluten-friendly product


        Beehive Red Butte Hatch Chili

          OUR STORE

          669 Main Street

          Montauk, NY  11954

          Phone: 631-668-0900

          Email: info@mtkgeneralstore.com

          For Orders Email:



          Open Saturday and Sunday 9-4

          • Grey Facebook Icon
          • Grey Google+ Icon
          • Grey Pinterest Icon
          • Grey Instagram Icon

          © 2017 by Montauk General Store Proudly created with Wix.com